The Greatest Pizza Stone and Baking Metal for 2023

Join Wirecutter’s newsletters to get unbiased evaluations, skilled recommendation, and the easiest offers despatched straight to your inbox.

A pizza stone is one of the best device for baking up crispy pies that’ll rival these made by your favourite restaurant, however it might additionally accomplish that rather more. After making greater than 50 pizzas, 24 flaky croissants, and 10 loaves of rustic bread on 4 stones and two baking steels, we expect the FibraMent-D Dwelling Oven Baking Stone is one of the best all-purpose stone for getting ready crisp pizza, crusty bread, and golden pastries.

The FibraMent-D baking stone is one of the best and most versatile stone we examined. This ¾-inch-thick ceramic slab holds sufficient warmth to bake a number of pro-quality pizzas back-to-back. And its coarse floor yields crispy bottoms and puffy crusts. However near-perfect pizza isn’t the one purpose we selected the FibraMent stone as our high decide. It’s an all-purpose baking floor that may enable you make ethereal croissants, gentle flaky biscuits, and pies with golden backside crusts. FibraMent additionally affords probably the most measurement choices of all our picks.

In order for you the absolute best probability at making a pizza with the black-spotted crust of a brick-oven Neapolitan pie, the ⅜-inch-thick Modernist Delicacies Baking Metal is your finest guess. It conducts warmth higher than any ceramic stone we examined, yielding pizzas with darkish and puffy crusts. And in contrast to the FibraMent, this sturdy metal plate is secure to make use of underneath any broiler and on the grill. However regardless that the Baking Metal is our favourite for pizza, it offers off an excessive amount of intense warmth for baking bread and more-delicate baked items, and it’ll scorch the bottoms of cookies or croissants. It additionally takes numerous muscle to hoist this 23-pound slab of metal out and in of the oven.

For those who’re an occasional baker or simply taken with a extra budget-friendly possibility, the Honey-Can-Do Rectangular Pizza Stone is a strong alternative. (This was referred to as the Previous Stone Oven Rectangular Pizza Stone. A consultant from Honey-Can-Do assured us that the stones are the identical.) The pizzas we baked on this stone ranked third among the many seven fashions we examined. That they had a barely paler, softer crust than pizzas we made with the Baking Metal or the FibraMent-D, although they had been nonetheless scrumptious and satisfying. This stone additionally produced crusty bread loaves with springy crumb. And its gentler warmth made it even higher than the FibraMent for baking croissants, which turned out so uniformly golden you’d have thought they got here from knowledgeable bakery. Plus, this stone is secure to make use of on the grill or underneath a broiler.